AI Governance POC Go/No-Go Scorecard: Exit Criteria Template
An AI governance POC go/no-go scorecard is a document agreed before testing begins. It lists weighted criteria, the evidence required for each, minimum thresholds, mandatory pass/fail gates, and the rules for a go, conditional go, or no-go decision. Gates cover runtime policy enforcement, agent identity, least-privilege permissions, tool-call governance, and audit logging. The weighted score covers the rest.
Why exit criteria must exist before the POC starts
The scorecard is agreed before testing begins, so the decision at the end of the POC is made against criteria that were approved in advance. Security, risk, compliance, platform, and business owners approve the scorecard before the POC starts, and all approvers sign the final decision record at the decision point (see the sign-off checklist below).
Scorecard template: criteria, weights, and evidence
The scorecard has four parts. Each one is defined before testing starts.
| Component | Description |
|---|---|
| Gates | Mandatory pass/fail criteria that no total score can offset. |
| Weighted criteria | Scored categories with agreed weights and minimum thresholds. |
| Evidence | Logs, test results, and configuration exports tied to each criterion. |
| Decision rules | Go, conditional go, and no-go definitions with named owners. |
Mandatory gates
Gates are pass/fail. They cover:
- Runtime policy enforcement
- Agent identity
- Least-privilege permissions
- Tool-call governance
- Audit logging
Weighted criteria
The weighted score covers the criteria that are not gates. Each scored category has an agreed weight and a minimum threshold. The risk owner approves the gate definitions, weights, and thresholds.
Setting thresholds and collecting evidence
Minimum thresholds are agreed for each weighted category before testing begins. Every criterion is tied to evidence: logs, test results, and configuration exports.
The security owner approves the enforcement, identity, and tool-call test cases. The compliance owner confirms that audit evidence meets review and retention needs.
Decision rules: go, conditional go, and no-go
The scorecard defines go, conditional go, and no-go outcomes, each with named owners. Because gates are mandatory, a failed gate is not offset by a high weighted score. Any conditional-go terms are recorded in the final decision record and signed by all approvers.
Operational and integration criteria
Operational and integration test conditions are confirmed before testing starts:
- The platform team confirms deployment, integration, and latency test conditions.
- The agent or business owner confirms that the test scenarios reflect real workflows.
Sign-off before the POC starts and at the decision point
- Security owner approves the enforcement, identity, and tool-call test cases.
- Risk owner approves gate definitions, weights, and thresholds.
- Compliance owner confirms that audit evidence meets review and retention needs.
- Platform team confirms deployment, integration, and latency test conditions.
- Agent or business owner confirms the test scenarios reflect real workflows.
- All approvers sign the final decision record and any conditional-go terms.