Comparison for financial services security leaders

    Shadow AI discovery methods compared for banks: CASB, DNS, egress proxy and endpoint

    No single method gives a bank full shadow AI visibility. CASB sees sanctioned and API-integrated SaaS, DNS sees domain lookups without content or user context, an egress proxy sees inspectable web traffic on managed paths, and endpoint agents see local applications, extensions and processes where they are deployed. Most banks will layer them. Discovery only produces findings, though. Stopping data from leaving requires policy enforcement on AI interactions at runtime, plus evidence that can be shown to examiners.

    Criteria for choosing and layering methods

    • Share of users and devices the method actually covers, including unmanaged, BYOD and off-network
    • Ability to identify AI sites, assistants, APIs, extensions and coding tools, and how the catalog is kept current
    • Whether findings carry user, device, time and destination detail
    • What prompt or user data is collected, where it is stored and who can access it
    • Deployment effort and performance impact on managed systems
    • Whether findings can be retained as evidence and tied to a documented response

    Discovery is a visibility problem with four partial views

    Shadow AI in a bank is not one thing. It includes public AI websites, browser-based assistants, desktop tools, coding assistants, browser extensions, direct API calls from scripts, and AI features that appear inside SaaS products the bank already approved. Each discovery method observes a different layer of the stack, so each reports a different subset of that activity.

    The selection question is therefore not which tool is best. It is which blind spots the bank can accept, which ones it must close with another layer, and what evidence each layer produces. A bank should expect examiners and model risk management functions to ask what AI use was found, how it was assessed and what was done about it. A finding that cannot be traced to a defined data source, time and user or device will be hard to defend.

    This comparison is organized around what each method can and cannot see, then around deployment effort, data handling and evidence quality.

    CASB, DNS, egress proxy and endpoint compared

    The table summarizes the typical strengths and blind spots of each method. Actual coverage depends on product, configuration and how much of the estate is routed through it, so treat these as questions to test in a pilot.

    • CASB: Sees: sanctioned and API-integrated SaaS, including AI features inside approved applications where the integration exposes them. Loses: AI sites and tools the bank has not connected or cataloged, and traffic outside the CASB path. Fidelity: strong on user and tenant context for covered apps. Evidence: good for governed SaaS, thin for unsanctioned use.
    • DNS filtering or logging: Sees: which domains were looked up, from which resolver or device, and when. Loses: content, prompts, user identity unless mapped separately, and any lookups that bypass the bank's resolvers, such as encrypted DNS to external providers. Fidelity: low, but broad and cheap. Evidence: a domain-level trail, not proof of what data was sent.
    • Egress or secure web proxy: Sees: inspectable web traffic from managed, on-network clients, with URL and often authenticated user context. Loses: unmanaged and BYOD devices, off-network use, certificate-pinned traffic and anything not sent through the proxy. Fidelity: medium to high where TLS inspection is in place. Evidence: strong for proxied sessions.
    • Endpoint agent: Sees: local applications, browser extensions, desktop assistants, coding tools and process activity, including off-network. Loses: devices without the agent and activity the agent is not built to classify. Fidelity: high for local activity. Evidence: strong per device, but only as complete as deployment coverage.

    Deployment effort, data handling and catalog upkeep

    DNS is usually the lightest to start with because most banks already control their resolvers. It also carries the least sensitive data, since it records domains rather than content. Its cost is in interpretation: someone has to maintain the mapping from domains to AI services, and that list changes constantly as new tools appear and existing products add AI features.

    An egress proxy is often already in place, but meaningful AI visibility depends on TLS inspection, policy tuning and exceptions for pinned applications. Inspection means the bank handles prompt content, which brings privacy, retention and access-control decisions that need to be settled with legal and privacy teams before rollout.

    CASB effort depends on how many SaaS applications can be connected through APIs and how current the vendor's application catalog is. Endpoint discovery has the highest deployment burden in a large bank: agent rollout, performance testing on managed images, change control and a plan for devices that cannot run the agent. In return it sees the local tools and extensions the other methods cannot.

    Across all four, the recurring maintenance task is the same: keeping the catalog of AI applications, domains and extensions current, and recording how each entry was classified. Code-level scanning of repositories can add a further layer by finding AI integrations embedded in applications, though it does not cover employees using external AI tools.

    How to layer the methods in a bank

    A practical sequence starts with breadth and adds fidelity where risk is highest. DNS gives the widest first view of which AI domains are being reached and from where. The egress proxy then adds user context and, where inspection is justified, content-level detail for managed on-network traffic. CASB covers the SaaS estate the bank has approved, including AI features inside those products. Endpoint discovery closes the gap for off-network use, local assistants, browser extensions and coding tools, prioritized first for developers and teams that handle sensitive data.

    Each layer should be judged by the gap it closes, not by its feature list. If most staff are on managed devices behind the proxy, proxy coverage may be adequate for web use. If a large share of work happens off-network or on unmanaged devices, endpoint coverage matters more. If AI is arriving mainly through approved SaaS, CASB findings and vendor feature reviews carry more weight.

    Correlation matters as much as coverage. A DNS hit, a proxy session and an endpoint process event describing the same activity should resolve to one finding with one classification and one owner. Without that, the bank collects several partial records and no defensible inventory.

    Where discovery ends and runtime enforcement begins

    Discovery tells a bank that AI use exists. It does not decide what an individual prompt or tool call may contain, and it does not stop sensitive data from leaving once an interaction starts. Reports and alerts arrive after the fact. Closing that gap requires policy enforced inside the interaction itself, and evidence of what that policy did.

    Trussed addresses that second step. It enforces policy in the execution path across AI sites, coding assistants, agents, tools, MCP servers and models, applying allow, redact, block, rate limit or escalation for human approval to individual interactions and tool calls. Enforcement is at runtime, not reviewed after the fact, and each decision generates audit-ready evidence mapped to frameworks including NIST and NYDFS. Trussed deploys self-managed in the customer's cloud with configurable retention and data residency, which bears directly on the data-handling questions above.

    Trussed has not made claims of bank deployments. Its depth is in insurance, a regulated financial sector, with 18+ months of continuous production in a regulated enterprise. For a bank, the relevant test is whether discovery findings feed a documented, enforced outcome that an examiner or model risk reviewer can inspect.

    What each method sees

    CASB

    Sanctioned and API-integrated SaaS

    DNS

    Domain lookups, no content or user context

    Egress proxy

    Inspectable web traffic on proxied paths

    Endpoint

    Local apps, extensions and processes where deployed

    Turn discovery findings into enforced, evidenced outcomes

    Talk through how runtime policy enforcement and audit-ready evidence fit alongside the discovery methods your bank already runs.

    Talk to an Expert